With the snow and unpleasantness upon us I had a hankering to watch Black Christmas. My beloved stopped me and made the pitch that we should save it. I agreed, but the itch was still there, so I thought I’d finally dive into to the 2019 reimagining from Blumhouse.
This film got far too much heat, so to speak, from the critics and fandom alike. I’ll preface by saying I did not love the flick but not at all for all the hyperbolic reasons swirling around last year. One of the obvious reasons the horror fandom reacted badly as per usual: A Remake. The mindset of horror fans on this issue is so schizophrenic. We love some remakes, detest others – why it’s almost as if people enjoy some film and not others.
The original Black Christmas (1974) is undoubtedly a classic and a very important footnote in any horror fans big book of important horror movies; particularly Slasher movies. This film maintains the story only insomuch as it involves a fraternity, sorority and takes place on a fictitious college campus during Christmas vacation. The 2019 incarnation departs from the original villain being a hidden killer or killers and has the holiday-ruining evil come in the form of a cult with supernatural properties and world dominating ambitions.
This is where the film lost me – and not because they drastically diverged from the 1974 original or its oddball 2006 sequel. An unpleasantly large amount of folks online took to burying this film solely on the basis that it was female driven and dealt with specific issues of social justice. Directed by Sophia Takal and written by April Woolfe, that aforementioned swath of keyboard warriors crusaded against the film by assuming the film itself was a crusade.
The film tackles misogyny, rape-culture and the enabling of offenders. I assume, because of that, a lot of angry insecure men felt the film was a knock against them. I thought it was a great subplot. Good horror often tackles with issues we find challenging as we are living through them. Some folks took the position that film shouldn’t be made with an agenda. I respect that thinking to the degree that I, personally, prefer things a little more subtle.
It isn’t that Black Christmas should not have tackled sexual assault or enabling culture on campus. It just hit the viewer over the head with it. Or perhaps it didn’t, but we were struggling with how it lines up with the original the entire time we watched it. Had this film been called something other than Black Christmas I think it would have played a lot different. The concept of an old boys’ club actually being an evil misogynistic cult is a great plot. The film fell victim to toxic folks online who can’t handle any social commentary with their film. Yet, that same crowd all praise classic horror full of social commentary – the just don’t like it when the commentary could possibly apply to them.